Saki:the case of the extra tile
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 2:53 am
I'm sure this must have been discussed to death back in 2009 but since it's relatively new to me, I'd like to bring it up again.
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=50235&start=30#p51061
Just after the 5 minute mark of episode 1, Saki has 15 tiles in her hand. This scene is over in an instant. From what I have read, and it wasn't much, it was obviously a goof in the animation. (and the manga too, I gather)
I also have some other observations, which didn't seem to be mentioned in the comments to that link.
http://www.sankakucomplex.com/2009/04/09/saki-cheating/
1) There seems to be 137 tiles in this game.
The wall has 14+17+11=42 stacks of 2 or 84 tiles, BUT, there is one missing in the middle of kyou-chan's wall, which leaves 83. (look carefully)
(This should have been very obvious to them when the game started)
The hands have 13+13+13+15=54. This totals 137. There are no discards yet.
2) In clockwise order, 26 stacks of 2 have been picked up by the players, or 52 tiles. It should be 53 (the 14th dealer tile).
There should only be 1 tile sitting in the front of Nodoka,s wall. (She should have noticed this)
So, in summation, Saki didn't take her 14th tile from Nodoka's wall but it magically appears in her hand (the 137th tile).
Her 15th tile belongs back in the middle of kyou-chan's wall. Lots of goofs in this scene, no cheating.
Okay, I know this stuff is all meaningless, but I'm having fun. Gimmee a break.
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=50235&start=30#p51061
Just after the 5 minute mark of episode 1, Saki has 15 tiles in her hand. This scene is over in an instant. From what I have read, and it wasn't much, it was obviously a goof in the animation. (and the manga too, I gather)
I also have some other observations, which didn't seem to be mentioned in the comments to that link.
http://www.sankakucomplex.com/2009/04/09/saki-cheating/
1) There seems to be 137 tiles in this game.
The wall has 14+17+11=42 stacks of 2 or 84 tiles, BUT, there is one missing in the middle of kyou-chan's wall, which leaves 83. (look carefully)
(This should have been very obvious to them when the game started)
The hands have 13+13+13+15=54. This totals 137. There are no discards yet.
2) In clockwise order, 26 stacks of 2 have been picked up by the players, or 52 tiles. It should be 53 (the 14th dealer tile).
There should only be 1 tile sitting in the front of Nodoka,s wall. (She should have noticed this)
So, in summation, Saki didn't take her 14th tile from Nodoka's wall but it magically appears in her hand (the 137th tile).
Her 15th tile belongs back in the middle of kyou-chan's wall. Lots of goofs in this scene, no cheating.
Okay, I know this stuff is all meaningless, but I'm having fun. Gimmee a break.