Game Critique Thread
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2013 5:36 am
I'm surprised a thread like this doesn't exist already, but...here it is.
We post games of ourselves playing mahjong and/or share advice for each other based on games we've played. Maybe this is kind of like a mahjong study group, but I think since it's a forum thread rather than a "let's all get together at a certain time and critique games" it's much less serious than that. I'm looking to improve my game and have a better sense of what kinds of risks I can take. I was a 4th dan, but recently fell to 3rd because I'm lacking something in my gameplay... I'm happy to try critiquing other people's games, but my opinion probably isn't very valuable except as just an opinion (i.e. I won't guarantee that it's the 'best' advice but that I'll try looking at every hand of every game that's posted~).
Here are my last 3 Tonpuusen (I'm trying to play exclusively tonpuusen to help me improve my game sense and knowing when to push vs. a hand/when not to):
2nd Place (+0)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022613gm-0 ... 0b2bb&tw=0
3rd Place (-18)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022614gm-0 ... bcdc1&tw=1
3rd Place (-20)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022614gm-0 ... 11c4e&tw=1
We post games of ourselves playing mahjong and/or share advice for each other based on games we've played. Maybe this is kind of like a mahjong study group, but I think since it's a forum thread rather than a "let's all get together at a certain time and critique games" it's much less serious than that. I'm looking to improve my game and have a better sense of what kinds of risks I can take. I was a 4th dan, but recently fell to 3rd because I'm lacking something in my gameplay... I'm happy to try critiquing other people's games, but my opinion probably isn't very valuable except as just an opinion (i.e. I won't guarantee that it's the 'best' advice but that I'll try looking at every hand of every game that's posted~).
Here are my last 3 Tonpuusen (I'm trying to play exclusively tonpuusen to help me improve my game sense and knowing when to push vs. a hand/when not to):
2nd Place (+0)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022613gm-0 ... 0b2bb&tw=0
3rd Place (-18)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022614gm-0 ... bcdc1&tw=1
3rd Place (-20)
牌譜: http://tenhou.net/0/?log=2013022614gm-0 ... 11c4e&tw=1