What would you discard?

Mauro · Post by **Mauro** » Sun Sep 13, 2015 2:08 pm

The playerd discarded

, waiting on

for the last group, then tanki wait on

waiting for a better wait; he drew

and riichied.

I was thinking about

, waiting for

for the last group and

for the pair.

(In the end we both would have got to riichi: I had also tanyao and pinfu, but he won so I don't know if I'd have won with my hand.)

Ignatius · Post by **Ignatius** » Sun Sep 13, 2015 3:23 pm

Not knowing other players hands I would have discarded

. To wait to complete

or

sets. Then I would riichi discarding

, or even

. This way I would have Riichi+Pinfu guaranteed, and probably Tanyao, and maybe an Uradora, or something.

Well, as another player did Riichi before me, i probably would try to play Damaten: To play fully closed, without Riichi in Tenpai state.

Mauro · Post by **Mauro** » Thu Sep 17, 2015 10:04 pm

Here I could either discard

(or

, but

has one out less) and go for 2 han itsu with less waits; or discard

and go for 1 han pinfu (and possibly tanyao, if I draw another

), with more waits but fewer han. What would you do? Would you chi

, if it was discarded?

Ignatius · Post by **Ignatius** » Thu Sep 17, 2015 10:55 pm

Being so early in the game, I would toss the

in a try to obtain tanyao + pinfu. No doubt for me, then, if I have the chance, I would discard the

.

Maybe others consider different options.

or2az · Post by **or2az** » Thu Sep 17, 2015 11:40 pm

I would also toss the

. The

will complete that 3rd chow and there are 11 of them left.
After you draw one of them, toss the

, riichi pinfu.
To rely on that

for a straight doesn't seem like a good idea to me but if you do happen to draw the

or the

after you toss the

but before you riichi , you could toss the

to add tanyao to the mix and then riichi.

riichi,pinfu,tanyao,menzen ron-----3han, 30fu, for 3900 pts
riichi,pinfu,tanyao,menzen tsumo--4han, 20fu, for 5200 pts
About half as much without tanyao.

Now that I look at the point spread, I wonder if tossing one of the cracks and going for the straight should be considered.
If I get it, the point totals above would double (substituting ittsuu for tanyao).
I definitely would not chi the

and open the hand. Need to riichi. Could end up a mangan (5han,20fu or 4han, 30fu kiriage).
I hear Washizu laughing? Hold on. I just realized that you have to draw that

before you complete the crack chow or else it's a penchan wait on the

and no pinfu. (and no mangan). The odds don't favor you on that one.
Think I will stick to the original plan and toss the

.
It's only East 3. First part of a long journey is a single step.

What would you discard?

What would you discard?

Re: What would you discard?

Re: What would you discard?

Re: What would you discard?

Re: What would you discard?